9/4/09

Entry 2

Game I Liked - Sonny

Main Topic - Progression of Difficulty

Sonny is a web based flash RPG game. In this game you take on the role of a newly created zombie with special powers and use these to fight against the corrupt organisation that created you. it features final fantasy like turn based combat with character inventory and items. simply the game is made up of gradually more challenging encounters, and you can save your progress before or after one of these. The encounters in Sonny can be broken up as Practise and Story encounters, and this is why the games progression of difficulty is done beautifully and as a result drew me in to complete the whole game. A Story encounter is more challenging than a Practice one and reveals the story though character dialog (usually before or after a fight), winning this encounter rewards you with experience, loot and allows you to continue through the story and/or access a new zone; losing results in Sonny's death and you will need to load from your last save. However between these "major" encounters you can basically hunt for a random fight via a Practice encounter. Practise encounters are slightly easier than a story encounter and still reward your with character experience and loot, however slightly less in amount and quality. Even losing a Practice encounter rewards a small amount of character experience (not killing Sonny as a Story encounter would). Practice encounters continue scale in difficulty as you win them but they will not exceed the current Story encounters or zones difficulty. As a result the game Sonny offers a continuous challenge to overcome with room for trial and error to perfect a strategy before attempting a big fight.   



Game I Disliked - The Armor RPG Experiment


Main Topic - Difficulty of First Challenge, Lack of game feed back, Starting Conditions


This game begins Arbitrarily with a menu screen where you need to pick a non descriptive-skill and then go straight into a Final Fantasy like turn based fight. This game being labeled as an "Experiment" excuses the lack of a storyline or introduction however the game also lacks any clear description of what abilities do and the advantages / disadvantages of using them. The game also has no tutorial, instead you must get through the first battle via trial and error, a horrible experience for a First Challenge. subsequently out of the rather large (and useless) range of abilities you can choose from, the way to win is to "power up" and "melee attack" and then rinse and repeat (although sometimes you can only power up or attack as there is also no clear indication of "action points"). In fact during combat the only information your presented with is your dwindling health and mana bars, as well as your opponents more resistant ones; your turn options that are only defined in categories, names and costs (usually mana); and yours and your opponent's attack damages.  In short this is a perfect example of a game lacking sufficient player feedback and starting condition information. The game basically fulfilling the role of an experimental engine would greatly benefit by including the following:-
  • A basic tutorial featuring:
    •  Definition of the combat system.
    •  An example of combat with basic use of attack and counter powers.
    •  Suggested tactics that can be employed.
    •  Explanation of player progression i.e. Leveling up, Attribute points, skill points etc...
  • Clear descriptions of what abilities do (Advantages / Disadvantages)
  • Finally a Save or Check point function so players do not need to start over.