10/2/09

Entry 6

Game I Liked: Chronotron

Main topic: Unique Gameplay mechanic


Within this brilliant puzzle game you control a robot that has a broken time machine and needs to collect parts for it. The key feature of this game is that you end up having to control different “instances” of your robot. As an example of gameplay: you start with your robot next to its time machine, there is a button the the right and the piece it needs is up in the top Left where the robot cannot reach. You move the robot onto the button and a platform starts rising on the left, but hopping off the button makes the platform fall. To solve this puzzle, you send your robot back to the time machine, and the time machine goes back in time to the point your “first” robot left the machine to stand on the button. You are now controlling the “present” robot and can now wait for the “past” robot to move onto the button and raise the platform, use the platform to reach the part, and return to the time machine. As such there does not appear to be a limit to how many instances of your robot you can have active at a time (but too many and your computer starts to have a heart-attack). In addition to the puzzle of pre, pre-planning, coordinating and timing your robot's actions; you need to avoid creating paradoxes, the most common of these is somehow preventing a past robot from returning to the time machine: thus preventing your current robot to even exist! Paradoxes result in the level resetting. The games design tailors to the amount of exact timing that is required by providing a timer that resets as you travel back in time to make another instance. I thoroughly enjoyed this unique puzzle mechanic, that required me to completely think differently from other puzzle games.


Game I Disliked: Night Driving


Main topic: Game controls, Player feedback, pointless rewards, no progression of difficulty.

This game simply starts with a drivers view of the inside of a car, travelling on a road at night. To control your car you steer with the mouse X axis and increase/decrease you speed via your Y axis. Hitting another car, going off the road or running out of points (that you get by driving fast and passing cars) results in you fatally crashing. In my opinion its failing points are:

  • Your steering controls, which are based off the mouse are overly sensitive making handling your car harder that it should be. In addition the steering wheel moves in relation to your steering of the car however the relation ship of this appears out of proportion which causes a kind of perceptional confusion.
  • The game provides not instructions, admittedly easy to pick up but does not explain what the numbers are on your dashboard (your points) are and their significance.
  • There is no indication of what speed you are going, nor is there a believable relation of your acceleration or deceleration. Your speed appears to have no affect on your survivability as even when moving at a crawling pace, hitting a car or running off the road still results in a fatal crash.
  • There is not progression of difficulty, the game being “sandbox” in nature has no end, but passing cars and driving fast (which generates points or stops/reduces their decline) does not visible become more difficult, thus even in terms of a survival game it offers limited motivation of play.
  • Finally, you've crashed but your stayed in there for a while... all you get is a replay button and no display of your score, time survived, cars passed top speed etc... thus this game has limited/no opportunity for bragging rights.
In conclusion I feel that this game is at best purely an experiment or at least unfinished.

9/25/09

Entry 5

Game I Liked: - Dino Run

Main Topic: Stylised Art, Exciting and Tension building gameplay 
Within this exciting, stylised and beautifully simple game you play as a small quick carnivorous dinosaur, “The” meteor has hit and you need to run for your life, outrunning the impacts shock wave of destruction and make it to your safe haven. This game is basically a arcade side-scrolling sprint game, where you can get points, bonuses and power ups in the form of dinosaur eggs along the way. The game Art is all made of chunky pixels giving it a Classic Arcade feel and displays some beautiful pixel artwork. Starting the game your environment is peaceful and Serene with grasing dinosaurs nearby. However paradise is lost with the fall and impact of the meteor, quickly all other dinosaurs start running and the sky and lighting become more threatening as the shock wave heads your way. The shock wave is the key element of this game that beautifully build tension. It takes the form of a destructive black mass that rumbles and “shakes” the screen and continues to darken the environment the closer it gets. Where this game excels is the action, each level becomes progressively more intense and difficult to navigate, avoiding lava bombs, stampeding dinosaurs, unstable terrain and dead falls this game pushes your reaction time to its limits.


Game I Disliked: - Maze Girl
Main topic: First Challenge, No rewards, no progression of difficulty
This game presents itself with a rather aesthetically pleasing tile and menu art. However upon starting the game you have a to control the Maze Girl girl via a top down view through a maze. The biggest problems about this is that the maze girl will continue to move the direction you last pressed at a breakneck pace, never stopping until she “falls” of the maze platform or somehow magically makes it to the finish. This game is ridiculously hard, employing no visible progression of difficulty and harsh losing conditions (you loose so quick that the menu music will sound like a broken record). Even if the game was designed to be a challenge to “hardcore” gamers, it however offers no rewards, i.e. saving your progress or presenting your score (for bragging rights as would be the primary motivation for the games suspected target audience). The game all though not original would have been better to at least have a progression in difficulty even taking the form of maze girl's run speed, to allow players to build up their reaction times before breaking their ARROW keys.



9/18/09

Entry 4

Game I liked - Wink: The Game 

Main Topic - Character abilities/ Game world interaction/ Magic Circle

This is my opinion is a cute and cleverly designed game, you play as wink a simple blue character who is out to save a princess. The game employs a witty narrator within the opening scene and ending scene which cleverly breaks the Magic Circle or the game, similarly to “breaking the fourth wall” and complements the games “tough-in-cheek” character. Within the Wink is rather stealthy being able to hide, sneak past (or up to) enemies and ambush them, and then grab their magic staff (as all enemies except for bosses are evil warlocks) and use it against them. Wink is also able to interact with the environment having very “original Prince of Persia” like abilities; jumping, grabbing, climbing etc.. In addition to Winks abilities he is able to utilise many objects within the game. For Example: a burning torch, Wink can extinguish the torch, which results in Wink being able to hide there (as the light prevents him) and/or attract the attention of enemies so that he can better by pass or ambush them; or, he could grab the torch and throw it as a weapon. As such this game provides a delightfully dynamic environment that a player can enjoy mastering their skills, exploration and a all round humour filled experience. 


Game I Disliked – Pharoh's Tomb 

Main Topic - Poor control and game view orientation, Target Audience

This game simply consists of movement and timing, the game world is presented as in isometric, and you use the either W,A,S,D or ARROW keys to move. Movement is immediate (no requirement to turn) you simply move the direction that correspond to what you press. This however is where the problem arises; as the game is in isomeric representation, the direction you move is offset by about 45°, so the relation of movement is UP = Top Right, Left = Top Left, Down = Bottom Left, Right = Bottom Right. As such playing the game (for me) was only made possible when I orientated my keyboard on the same skew this proving to make playing the game feel awkward. Personally I feel the game fails to tailor to the target audience, other isometric games avoid this awkward orientation issue by having a more steering based controls, you need to turn and then depending on what direction your facing, move forward or backward. I understand why they designed the controls this was, as the designer did not want the player to “waste time” turning to move a direction, as the game is rather fast paced. Despite the game looking quite pretty in isometric, I feel the gameplay would of benefited from a simple top-down view.



9/11/09

Entry 3

Game I Liked - Paladin: The Game 

Main Topic - Character abilities, Reward System

Within Paladin: The Game, you start out as a young boy in training and learn the basics in a story driven tutorial. Some years later your Call to Adventure is an unexpected attack on your sanctuary by evil forces, your mentor quickly reveals your hidden legacy, a magic sword that unleashes the power of the Paladin in you so that you might stop the evil forces once and for all. The game takes the form of a simple side-scrolling platform game, but also has elements of a RPG as you can gain levels and develop the Paladin to suit your play style. The game offers many different increasingly powerful abilities that you can unlock by gaining higher levels. these abilities can be increased in power and effectiveness by spending "power points" (gained with every level) to increase their rank. The higher rank of the ability, the higher the cost of Aura (Mana) in most cases. These abilities include:-
  • Aura Shield: creates a defensive shield in front of the Paladin, protecting attacks from one direction at a time, however if enemies get behind the shield they can attack normally.
  • Aura Blast: a directional energy bolt attack.
  • Shockwave: a ground based omni-directional attack that knocks down enemies and inflicts minimal damage.
  • Power attack: More power full melee attack
  • Turn Undead: slowly damages all enemies within the area and slows or stuns them depending on the abilities rank.
  • Judgement: very damaging, very costly attack that effects all enemies on screen.
  • Flight: Toggle ability that allows the paladin to fly, unlike other abilities increased rank of this ability lowers the continual cost of Aura. (other abilities can still be used while flying)
With these abilities and in conjunction with customisable attributes, the game provides a player with enough options to tailor the Paladin to their play style and thus strengthening your Paladin in a I feel, effective Rewards system of facility. 






Game I Disliked - DragonSlayer v1.2

Main Topic - Gameplay Difficulty, Limited / lacking player abilities

DragonSlayer is a defence game, where you defend your wizard tower against angry dragons that fly in from all anywhere within a 180° arc. Starting the game you get brief instructions on how to play, and a optional attribute to increase, such as attack power, speed, increase tower health etc... Within the game the players view is centred on the wizards cross-hair and you need to move this around to aim at incoming dragons and bring them into view, at the bottom left there is a radar-like display that shows roughly where the incoming dragons are and what speed they are coming in. To fend off the dragons the wizard has a magic bolt attack (which you can upgrade its power and recharge speed) as well as an ability to deflect the dragons fireball attacks. As these are all of the abilities that you have at your disposal the game is very challenging, and unforgiving. To succeed you need to have pin point accuracy and timing to hit the dragons with your attack, as well as near perfect mouse control to follow a dragons fireball and repeatedly hit the SPACE button (as this is your only way to “deflect” attacks). Overall the game is similar to other games in it genre back lacks reliable and easy to learn controls, which makes playing the game more taxing than challenging.

9/4/09

Entry 2

Game I Liked - Sonny

Main Topic - Progression of Difficulty

Sonny is a web based flash RPG game. In this game you take on the role of a newly created zombie with special powers and use these to fight against the corrupt organisation that created you. it features final fantasy like turn based combat with character inventory and items. simply the game is made up of gradually more challenging encounters, and you can save your progress before or after one of these. The encounters in Sonny can be broken up as Practise and Story encounters, and this is why the games progression of difficulty is done beautifully and as a result drew me in to complete the whole game. A Story encounter is more challenging than a Practice one and reveals the story though character dialog (usually before or after a fight), winning this encounter rewards you with experience, loot and allows you to continue through the story and/or access a new zone; losing results in Sonny's death and you will need to load from your last save. However between these "major" encounters you can basically hunt for a random fight via a Practice encounter. Practise encounters are slightly easier than a story encounter and still reward your with character experience and loot, however slightly less in amount and quality. Even losing a Practice encounter rewards a small amount of character experience (not killing Sonny as a Story encounter would). Practice encounters continue scale in difficulty as you win them but they will not exceed the current Story encounters or zones difficulty. As a result the game Sonny offers a continuous challenge to overcome with room for trial and error to perfect a strategy before attempting a big fight.   



Game I Disliked - The Armor RPG Experiment


Main Topic - Difficulty of First Challenge, Lack of game feed back, Starting Conditions


This game begins Arbitrarily with a menu screen where you need to pick a non descriptive-skill and then go straight into a Final Fantasy like turn based fight. This game being labeled as an "Experiment" excuses the lack of a storyline or introduction however the game also lacks any clear description of what abilities do and the advantages / disadvantages of using them. The game also has no tutorial, instead you must get through the first battle via trial and error, a horrible experience for a First Challenge. subsequently out of the rather large (and useless) range of abilities you can choose from, the way to win is to "power up" and "melee attack" and then rinse and repeat (although sometimes you can only power up or attack as there is also no clear indication of "action points"). In fact during combat the only information your presented with is your dwindling health and mana bars, as well as your opponents more resistant ones; your turn options that are only defined in categories, names and costs (usually mana); and yours and your opponent's attack damages.  In short this is a perfect example of a game lacking sufficient player feedback and starting condition information. The game basically fulfilling the role of an experimental engine would greatly benefit by including the following:-
  • A basic tutorial featuring:
    •  Definition of the combat system.
    •  An example of combat with basic use of attack and counter powers.
    •  Suggested tactics that can be employed.
    •  Explanation of player progression i.e. Leveling up, Attribute points, skill points etc...
  • Clear descriptions of what abilities do (Advantages / Disadvantages)
  • Finally a Save or Check point function so players do not need to start over.

8/28/09

Entry 1


Game I Liked - Prince of Persia: Sands of Time

Main Topic - Gameplay mechanic: Dagger of Time

This 3D action/adventure platform game offers endless free flowing action: Playing as the Prince you control a character with near supernatural agility and skill, pulling of moves like wall running, flipping from flagpole-like protrusions and making gigantic leaps with relative ease. The nature of how rather simple player input makes the Prince execute these amazing stunts one after the other is what I believe makes game a benchmark for future 3D action / adventure platformers. Even though the game offers intuitive iteration with the Prince and his environment, the puzzles and obstacles require precision, innovation and timing and often with little room for respite between these (as having a time limit to complete these tasks and obstacles are not uncommon). Despite this, this challenging game has avoided being overly taxing via various clever mechanics within the game. The Prince, not only armed with sword also possess a powerful magical dagger, the Dagger of Time, which allows him to alter time, primarily it functions as a limited “undo” ability, but also can slow and even freeze time. This magical “undo” dagger, allows a quick error of judgement to be rectified and fatal mistakes avoided. Of course this powerful mechanic is not without its limitations (starting with less than 4 seconds of undo) and requires resources Sands of Time (which you can find or pick-up off defeated enemies) to function and cannot exceed the maximum sand slots. Though throughout the game you can increase your maximum Sand slots and gain other powers by Sand Fountains. I feel that this revolutionary mechanic has allowed this Pakour style 3D platformer which offered new (in its time) challenges to the player, made the game seem not easy, but achievable.


Game I Disliked - Pirates of the Caribbean

Main Topic - Gameplay mechanic/First Challenge: Naval Combat

This game, even though its only similarities to the Disney movie, are that there are pirates and its in the Caribbean. As soon as you start this game it promises:-
  • Political intrigue 
  • Sword fights 
  • Sea Navigation 
  • Merchant Trading / Pirating 
  • Ship upgrading 
  • Naval Combat
Unfortunately this last feature is what made me eventually give up the game. The gameplay is in the form of a third person action adventure, and naval gamely is similar to this as well. You can control your ship basically with the directional buttons and have access to various different abilities, reefing and hoisting sails... but mostly attacking, your starting ship is small, but quick but also only has 3 small cannons. to fire a cannon you need to select which cannon that you will "man" and then your are presented with a first person view, looking down the barren of the cannon. Here the game presents you with a wind indicator and cross-hair, you need to aim at your target (a enemy ship) compensate the wind, and then finally time your shot with the pitch (the rocking) of your own ship. This attempt at realism was I felt was well design if a little too challenging. however while you are manning your cannons, no one is controlling the ship, and you can control the ship while manning a cannon, so you would have to quickly exit the "cannon" view and back to the "ship" view and steer, then man the cannon again to have another shot. The whole time your trying to balance this the computer player is expertly controlling their ship while firing with a better aim. As such winning a naval fight is close to impossible; and losing a fight counts as your character death so you have to load from your last checkpoint (which would be close to 2 min of gameplay to the naval battle again). To sum up, the First Challenge (of naval combat)  demanded too much multi-tasking for a player, it offered no naval combat tutorial and failing the storyline battle would result in a discouraging reload to the games distant check points. I feel the game would of benefited from a symbiotic AI, one that either controls the ship while your on the cannons, or fire while your steering, because a captain is not supposed control their ship AND fire her guns.