8/28/09

Entry 1


Game I Liked - Prince of Persia: Sands of Time

Main Topic - Gameplay mechanic: Dagger of Time

This 3D action/adventure platform game offers endless free flowing action: Playing as the Prince you control a character with near supernatural agility and skill, pulling of moves like wall running, flipping from flagpole-like protrusions and making gigantic leaps with relative ease. The nature of how rather simple player input makes the Prince execute these amazing stunts one after the other is what I believe makes game a benchmark for future 3D action / adventure platformers. Even though the game offers intuitive iteration with the Prince and his environment, the puzzles and obstacles require precision, innovation and timing and often with little room for respite between these (as having a time limit to complete these tasks and obstacles are not uncommon). Despite this, this challenging game has avoided being overly taxing via various clever mechanics within the game. The Prince, not only armed with sword also possess a powerful magical dagger, the Dagger of Time, which allows him to alter time, primarily it functions as a limited “undo” ability, but also can slow and even freeze time. This magical “undo” dagger, allows a quick error of judgement to be rectified and fatal mistakes avoided. Of course this powerful mechanic is not without its limitations (starting with less than 4 seconds of undo) and requires resources Sands of Time (which you can find or pick-up off defeated enemies) to function and cannot exceed the maximum sand slots. Though throughout the game you can increase your maximum Sand slots and gain other powers by Sand Fountains. I feel that this revolutionary mechanic has allowed this Pakour style 3D platformer which offered new (in its time) challenges to the player, made the game seem not easy, but achievable.


Game I Disliked - Pirates of the Caribbean

Main Topic - Gameplay mechanic/First Challenge: Naval Combat

This game, even though its only similarities to the Disney movie, are that there are pirates and its in the Caribbean. As soon as you start this game it promises:-
  • Political intrigue 
  • Sword fights 
  • Sea Navigation 
  • Merchant Trading / Pirating 
  • Ship upgrading 
  • Naval Combat
Unfortunately this last feature is what made me eventually give up the game. The gameplay is in the form of a third person action adventure, and naval gamely is similar to this as well. You can control your ship basically with the directional buttons and have access to various different abilities, reefing and hoisting sails... but mostly attacking, your starting ship is small, but quick but also only has 3 small cannons. to fire a cannon you need to select which cannon that you will "man" and then your are presented with a first person view, looking down the barren of the cannon. Here the game presents you with a wind indicator and cross-hair, you need to aim at your target (a enemy ship) compensate the wind, and then finally time your shot with the pitch (the rocking) of your own ship. This attempt at realism was I felt was well design if a little too challenging. however while you are manning your cannons, no one is controlling the ship, and you can control the ship while manning a cannon, so you would have to quickly exit the "cannon" view and back to the "ship" view and steer, then man the cannon again to have another shot. The whole time your trying to balance this the computer player is expertly controlling their ship while firing with a better aim. As such winning a naval fight is close to impossible; and losing a fight counts as your character death so you have to load from your last checkpoint (which would be close to 2 min of gameplay to the naval battle again). To sum up, the First Challenge (of naval combat)  demanded too much multi-tasking for a player, it offered no naval combat tutorial and failing the storyline battle would result in a discouraging reload to the games distant check points. I feel the game would of benefited from a symbiotic AI, one that either controls the ship while your on the cannons, or fire while your steering, because a captain is not supposed control their ship AND fire her guns.